Is Hiring a Digital Marketer Worth It for a Small Business?

Is Hiring a Digital Marketer Worth It for a Small Business?

If you’ve ever looked at your marketing budget and wondered whether hiring a digital marketer is actually worth the money, you’re not alone.

Clients do not necessarily say that they are unsure whether hiring a digital marketer is worth it, but I can often tell that they are trying to understand the value it could bring.

Their focus can sometimes be on how much they need to spend initially, without thinking as much about the additional value that investment could bring further down the line.

Many business owners know they need to do something to attract more enquiries, improve their website or increase their visibility online. However, when the initial cost is their main focus, it can be difficult to judge whether bringing in a digital marketer will create enough value over time or simply become another expense.

The honest answer is that it depends.

A good digital marketer can help you generate more enquiries, improve your website performance and give you a clearer understanding of what’s working. A poor one can cost you time, money and a lot of frustration.

The challenge for most business owners is knowing the difference.

The Real Cost of Doing Nothing

Many businesses don’t deliberately choose not to market themselves.

What usually happens is that business owners push marketing down the priority list.

You’re serving clients, dealing with suppliers, managing staff, pricing jobs and handling everything else that comes with running a business.

Then, before you know it:

  • You haven’t updated your website in two years.
  • Your Google Business Profile is out of date.
  • No one knows where your enquiries come from.
  • Your social media is inconsistent.
  • You’ve tried a few marketing activities but aren’t sure if any of them worked.

The result isn’t just a lack of growth. It’s uncertainty.

You don’t know what to focus on next because you don’t have enough information to make confident decisions.

Why Many Business Owners Become Frustrated With Marketing

The truth is that most business owners don’t hate marketing.

They hate:

  • Confusion.
  • Spending money without knowing what the return was.
  • Hearing different advice from different people.
  • The feeling that they’re constantly busy but not necessarily making progress.

One of the biggest mistakes I see is businesses focusing on marketing activity without first deciding what outcome they need it to produce.

  • More website traffic sounds great.
  • More social media followers sounds impressive.
  • More clicks and impressions can look positive on a report.

But none of those things automatically lead to enquiries or sales.

What matters is whether marketing is helping your business grow.

What Does a Digital Marketer Actually Bring to the Table?

Many people assume a digital marketer’s job is simply to ‘do marketing’.

In reality, the most valuable thing a good digital marketer provides is clarity.

A digital marketer needs to understand the business owner’s goals and the current state of their marketing.

Without knowing the current situation and what the business is aiming for, it is difficult to give effective advice.

I would normally ask what the client is currently doing for marketing, what they have tried in the past and what has or has not worked.

Helping me to understand what they are trying to improve and who their target audience is.

I would be cautious of a marketer who does not take the time to understand the business properly, focuses on traffic and impressions without connecting them to enquiries or sales, or keeps recommending more budget without explaining why or providing data to support the recommendation.

I try to avoid jargon and buzzwords where possible and explain things in a way that someone without marketing knowledge can understand.

If a marketer cannot explain something in simple terms and instead uses a lot of complicated language, it may suggest that they are trying to mask something or do not fully understand it themselves.

You should always feel comfortable asking a marketer to explain something if you do not understand it.

Marketing clarity usually comes from three areas:

Identifying What’s Already Working

Many businesses have opportunities right in front of them but don’t realise it.

For example:

  • Certain pages on their website generate most of their enquiries.
  • One advertising campaign is performing significantly better than others.
  • Existing customers are their most effective source of referrals.
  • One service is attracting far more interest than the rest.

Without looking at the data, these opportunities can go unnoticed.

For example, I have worked with a client who wanted to increase their conversions, and the data suggested that concentrating more of the available budget on an area already showing potential could improve the results.

Rather than increasing the overall budget straight away, some of the existing ads were paused so that more of the available budget could be focused on one area.

Although the amount being spent on that one area initially seemed quite high, the results over the next couple of months significantly improved the return on investment.

Based on the data we gathered and the sales that were made, the client decided to keep the increased budget for that particular service.

This showed focusing more of the available budget on something that was already showing potential could produce better results.

Helping You Prioritise

One of the biggest challenges for business owners is knowing where to focus.

  • Should you invest in SEO?
  • Run Google Ads?
  • Improve your website?
  • Start using LinkedIn?
  • Create more content?

The answer is rarely “all of them at once”.

A good marketer helps identify the activities most likely to generate a return based on your goals, budget and situation.

If a business thinks it needs more website traffic, I would first look at how much traffic it is already getting and what visitors do when they land on the website.

This can help show whether the right target audience is being attracted and, if they are, why they are not converting.

One way to tackle this could be to A/B test a second version of the landing page and compare the results before spending more money on bringing additional visitors to the website.

Providing Accountability

This is often overlooked. The businesses that make the best progress usually have a plan and someone helping them stick to it.

Without accountability, even good ideas get pushed aside when things get busy.

During a regular review, I generally start by asking how the client is and how they feel the business has been going recently.

We would discuss any new developments or concerns, as well as looking at the data that is available.

Based on this, we would decide together what should change, what should stay the same and what we may need to do more of.

Running a business, as well as dealing with day to day life, can be very busy, so it is easy for tasks or decisions to be forgotten.

I create a list of the tasks we have discussed, who is responsible for each one and when it needs to be completed.

Where necessary, I will ask for an update on a task.

This provides a reminder, helps keep the client accountable and makes sure their marketing continues moving in the right direction.

When Hiring a Digital Marketer Probably Isn’t Worth It

Let’s be honest.

There are situations where bringing in a marketer isn’t the right decision.

For example:

  • You have no capacity to take on more work.
  • Your service offering isn’t fully developed yet.
  • You haven’t worked out your pricing.
  • You’re still validating your business idea.
  • You aren’t ready to invest either time or budget into growth.

In these situations, it may be more sensible to focus on getting the foundations right first.

Marketing tends to amplify what’s already there.

If the foundations are weak, marketing won’t solve the underlying problems.

I have worked with businesses that wanted to continue with a particular marketing activity, even when the data suggested another approach could be more effective.

In those situations, I explain my recommendation and monitor the results.

If the activity improves visibility but does not lead to enough enquiries or sales, I will be honest about it and recommend a change in direction.

That may even mean pausing part of my own work so the available budget can be used where it has a better chance of producing a return.

I believe the advice should be based on what is best for the business, rather than continuing a service simply because the client is already paying for it.

When It Usually Makes Sense

Hiring a digital marketer becomes much more valuable when:

  • You want more enquiries.
  • You know your service works.
  • You have capacity to grow.
  • You’re unsure where to focus your marketing efforts.
  • You’re spending money but don’t know what’s generating results.
  • You want expert input without hiring a full time marketing employee.

This is where an external perspective can be particularly useful.

Sometimes the biggest value isn’t the marketing itself.

It’s having someone who can look at the bigger picture, challenge assumptions and help you make better decisions.

The Question Isn’t Really “Can I Do My Own Marketing?”

Most business owners are capable of learning marketing.

The real question is whether that’s the best use of their time.

You could learn:

  • SEO.
  • Google Ads.
  • Analytics.
  • Conversion optimisation.
  • Content strategy.

But every hour spent learning those skills is an hour not spent serving clients, building relationships or running the business.

For some people, doing it themselves makes perfect sense.

For others, getting guidance from someone who works with marketing every day can accelerate progress and help avoid costly mistakes.

How can I work out which approach is right for me?

If a business owner has a limited budget but plenty of spare time or capacity, I would recommend starting with a free initial conversation with a digital marketer.

They may be able to provide some useful tips on what to look at and what the business owner could carry out themselves.

Once the business starts bringing in more work or has built up more budget, they can engage with a digital marketer further to help get things moving.

If the business owner does not have the time, capacity or knowledge to do the work themselves, starting on a consultancy basis can provide some direction.

They can then use done-for-you services for the areas where they need more practical support.

For a more established business owner, the decision can be simpler: if they can make more money by focusing on their own work than it would cost to outsource the marketing, bringing in a marketing professional makes sense.

How involved the business owner should be depends on their budget and how much capacity they have to carry out parts of the marketing themselves.

Whatever level of support is chosen, I would still recommend that the business owner remains involved through regular review meetings. This allows them to see what is working, understand what is not and share anything happening within the business that may not be visible from the outside.

Final Thoughts

Hiring a digital marketer shouldn’t be about handing over responsibility and hoping for the best.

It should be about gaining clarity, understanding what’s working, what isn’t and having a practical plan for moving your business forward.

If your marketing feels inconsistent, confusing or difficult to measure, it may be worth stepping back and looking at the bigger picture before investing more money into additional activity.

Because in many cases, the biggest problem isn’t a lack of marketing.

It’s a lack of direction.

Creative man, thinking and glass board for project management, marketing or planning at office.

Thinking About Your Marketing?

If you’re thinking about your own marketing, I would start by asking where you believe your enquiries and sales currently come from and where you have been focusing your efforts.

I would then review the available data, including their website analytics, search performance, Google Business Profile, social media and advertising accounts.

The data can sometimes highlight opportunities or problems that the client was not previously aware of.

By combining this with the client’s knowledge of their business, I can recommend which areas should be prioritised.

We could then continue on a consultancy basis, reviewing the data regularly and adjusting the focus over time, or I could provide done-for-you support by improving the website, managing advertising campaigns or carrying out SEO work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is hiring a digital marketer worth it for a small business?

Hiring a digital marketer can be worthwhile when your business has a proven offer, capacity to grow and a clear need for more enquiries.

The value should come from clearer priorities, measurable activity and better-informed decisions.

When should a small business hire a digital marketer?

Consider hiring a digital marketer if you keep postponing marketing, your website generates too few enquiries, you cannot track your return or you need expert direction before investing in SEO, advertising or a new website.

How much does a digital marketing consultant cost in the UK?

Costs depend on the consultant’s experience, the support required and whether they advise, deliver campaigns or both.

You might pay for a one off review, a defined project or monthly support.

Compare scope, outcomes and reporting rather than price alone.

Should a small business outsource its marketing or hire in house?

Outsourcing suits businesses that need specialist or flexible support without employing a full-time marketer.

An in-house hire may make more sense when the workload is consistent, the budget is sustainable and marketing needs close day to day involvement.

Which digital marketing channel should a small business start with?

Start with the channel that matches where customers look for help, how quickly you need results, your budget and your ability to follow up.

SEO and local search can build visibility, while Google Ads may meet existing demand more quickly.

How long does digital marketing take to produce results?

Timelines depend on the channel, competition, website and starting position.

Paid campaigns can generate traffic quickly but need testing, while SEO and organic visibility take longer to build.

Set realistic milestones and measure enquiries, conversions and revenue.

How do I choose the right digital marketer for my business?

Choose someone who asks about your goals, customers, margins and capacity before suggesting tactics.

They should explain their approach, scope, expectations and measurement clearly.

Avoid guaranteed rankings, vague reporting or pressure to commit before they understand your needs.

Start a free initial conversation with me

Where we can go through your current marketing setup to discover what works, what needs improving and what the next steps could be..

If you want to handle it from there on your own, or if you would like me to get involved is completely up to you.

If you want to start a conversation with me, surrounding your Digital Marketing Strategy or the wider aspects of your digital marketing.

Click the button below to pick a suitable time or fill in the form with your message.

Name
Distribution list